Utah • Colorado • Business Litigation

Precision strategy for high-stakes conflict.

Complex commercial and business litigation for companies, executives, investors, and disputes against well-resourced adversaries—breach of fiduciary duty, corporate governance, shareholder and partnership disputes, business fraud, civil appeals, and U.S. Supreme Court amicus work.

Also available for emergency TRO, injunction, and noncompete defense when urgent business court action is required.

Emergency hearing for noncompete breach? Same-day consultation available.

20+ years
Business litigation & appeals
75+ appeals
State & federal courts
AV Preeminent
Peer rating
Utah & Colorado
Commercial disputes

Practice Areas

Practice Areas

Commercial, Business & Fraud

Breach of fiduciary duty, corporate governance, shareholder and partnership disputes, plaintiff-side business fraud, interference, and fraudulent transfers.

Learn more →

Emergency TRO & Injunction Defense

Immediate response for businesses facing temporary restraining orders, preliminary injunctions, and other urgent court deadlines.

Learn more →

Immediate Representation for Noncompete & Restrictive Covenant Disputes

Cease-and-desist demands, TRO threats, and Utah one-year statutory limits handled with same-day strategy and filings.

Learn more →

Appeals & Amicus Curiae

Civil appeals and amicus work in Utah, Colorado, the Tenth Circuit, and the U.S. Supreme Court.

Learn more →

Employment Litigation

Trial-focused counsel for noncompete enforcement, Utah Wage Claim Act matters, discrimination defenses, and separation agreements.

Learn more →

Insurance & Bad Faith

Coverage opinions, declaratory actions, and first- and third-party bad-faith litigation.

Learn more →

Trust & Probate

Trustee removal, accountings, undue influence, unauthorized amendments, and contested fiduciary actions.

Learn more →

Real Property

Partition, boundary, quiet title, lis pendens, wrongful foreclosure, and execution sales.

Learn more →

Products & Injury

Utah product liability attorney defense for manufacturers, premises owners, and transportation companies facing catastrophic injury claims.

Learn more →

Attorney Ethics & Discipline

Disciplinary defense and character & fitness representation with one attorney, one conflict check, and complete discretion.

Learn more →

Commercial Litigation

Business and Commercial Litigation

Summary judgment in high-exposure cases
Complex, multi-year matters resolved
Emergency relief to protect assets and business continuity

Sarah leads SpencerWillson's commercial litigation practice. Recognitions include Best Lawyers (Commercial Litigation), Mountain States Super Lawyers, and Utah Legal Elite. Known as a “summary judgment lawyer,” she has secured major victories without trial, including UTA v. Greyhound (12 years; three appeals) and Feasel v. Tracker Marine (two appeals over 10 years).

Under emergency pressure? Visit the Emergency TRO & Injunction Defense page for rapid opposition, counterclaims, and cross-motions when hearings are days away.

When restrictive covenant disputes escalate to emergency hearings, procedural timing becomes critical—coordinating TRO responses, preliminary injunction strategy, and potential appeals on a single track.

Recent Results & Active Matters

2025Order granting leave to preserve discovery to identify cyberattackers under the Utah Computer Data Abuse Act.
Nov 2024Partial summary judgment on an ethics-violation claim for an attorney client; remaining claim resolved by settlement.
2025Defending securities fraud and civil RICO claims in federal court involving complex financial transactions (MSJ filed; pending Oct. 2025).
2025Pursuing summary judgment in breach of contract and fraud case against a hardware/software developer that concealed performance deficiencies (MSJ filed; pending Oct. 2025).

Appellate

Civil Appeals

Civil appeals across commercial, tort, statutory, administrative, and constitutional matters. 75+ appellate cases; frequent arguments in Utah appellate courts and the Tenth Circuit; amicus briefing on issues of broad industry impact.

Appellate reversals across multiple courts
Amicus briefs on national-impact issues

Oral Arguments (selected)

Cohen Braffits v. Shae Financial (Second Argument)
Utah Court of Appeals

Commercial litigation involving loan agreements and foreclosure proceedings.

Watch Oral Argument →
Aguila v. Planned Parenthood
Utah Court of Appeals

Appeal challenging dismissal of negligent hiring and breach of fiduciary duty claims.

Watch Oral Argument →
Christmann v. State Farm
Idaho Supreme Court

Underinsured motorist coverage case addressing enforceability and subrogation actions.

Watch Oral Argument →
Brown v. Nationwide
Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals

Insurance coverage dispute involving UIM benefits.

Representative Appeals & Amicus

Estate of Cordery v. Intermountain Health, Inc. (2025)Petition for writ of certiorari on the lost-chance doctrine in medical malpractice.
Blackwell v. The Pearl (2025)Court-appointed pro bono representation in Fair Housing Act racial discrimination appeal.
Cohen Braffits Estates Development v. Shae Financial Group (2025)Appeal of fee award focusing on timeliness and mootness after foreclosure sale.
Truman v. Russek (2025)Appeal of summary judgment in fraud and breach of contract case involving Michael Jordan memorabilia.
Amicus: Mead Johnson & Co. v. Greear (2026) — Due Process limits on state-court personal jurisdiction over aggregated nationwide mass-tort claims.
Amicus: Bissonnette v. LePage Bakeries Park St., LLC (2023) — Addressed the Federal Arbitration Act's "transportation workers" exception.
Amicus: Laufer v. Acheson Hotels (2023) — Article III standing in digital informational injury cases.

Amicus

Amicus Briefs

Regular representation of amici at the U.S. Supreme Court, federal circuits, and state supreme courts.

Mead Johnson & Co. v. Greear (2026)Authored petition-stage brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Illinois Defense Counsel on the Due Process limits of general and specific personal jurisdiction where 12,500+ nationwide mass-tort claims were aggregated in two Illinois counties.
Download brief (PDF)
Hain Celestial Group, Inc. v. Palmquist (2025)Authored an amicus brief for the Atlantic Legal Foundation concerning post-judgment vertical forum shopping and its impact on procedural fairness.
Download brief (PDF)
Sprout Foods, Inc. v. Gillian Davidson & Samuel Davidson (2025)Authored for the Atlantic Legal Foundation addressing FDCA preemption of state-law claims and the need for uniform food labeling standards.
Download brief (PDF)
Medical Marijuana, Inc. v. Horn (2024)Authored merits brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Atlantic Legal Foundation challenging the Second Circuit's expansive view of RICO personal injury damages.
Download brief (PDF)
Medical Marijuana, Inc. v. Horn (2023)Authored petition brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Atlantic Legal Foundation on special damages liability from employment harms under RICO.
Download brief (PDF)
Bissonnette v. LePage Bakeries Park St., LLC (2023)Authored for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Atlantic Legal Foundation on the Federal Arbitration Act’s transportation worker exception.
Download brief (PDF)
Laufer v. Acheson Hotels (2023)Authored merits brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy on Article III standing in digital informational injury cases and separation of powers.
Download brief (PDF)
Laufer v. Acheson Hotels (2023)Authored petition brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy on Article III standing in digital informational injury cases and separation of powers.
Download brief (PDF)
Coinbase, Inc. v. Bielski (2023)Authored a petition-stage brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy regarding judicial authority to deny stays during arbitrability appeals.
Download brief (PDF)
Flowers Foods, Inc. v. Brock (2024)Authored a petition brief for DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Atlantic Legal Foundation addressing transportation worker status under the Federal Arbitration Act.
Download brief (PDF)

Coverage

Insurance Coverage

Coverage opinions and declaratory actions for insurers and insureds across CGL, professional liability, auto, title, workers' compensation, and products and completed operations.

Representative Matters

UM "Phantom Vehicle"Proved burden and policy terms for unidentified drivers.
Non-Owned AutosAvoided CGL exposure outside named insured's business operations.
Duty to DefendApplied four-corners rule to intentional or illegal acts.
Additional Insured TendersManaged contract-assumed liabilities across construction and leases.

Bad Faith

Bad-Faith Insurance Litigation

Prosecution and defense of bad-faith claims across auto, premises, title, and products lines, plus agent-negligence actions.

Representative Matters

Defense of InsurersFirst-party bad-faith claims with high UM/UIM limits.
Fire-Loss Bad FaithRecoveries for denied or underpaid claims.
Title Bad FaithCoverage denials involving seller authority disputes.
Strategic Co-CounselCollaboration with counsel from State Farm v. Campbell lineage.

Property

Property Litigation

Full-spectrum property litigation including partitions, boundaries, title and coverage, eminent domain, and execution sales.

Same-day consultations available. Email documentation securely and we will coordinate surveyors, engineers, and appraisal professionals when disputes escalate.

Representative Matters

2025Partition referee appointed in complex co-ownership dispute.
2025Pending summary judgment on restrictive covenant enforceability post-foreclosure.
Surface vs. Subsurface RightsInjunction and valuation of extracted materials.
Lis Pendens ValidityStatutory challenges in equitable and fraud disputes.
Boundary, Trespass & EncroachmentSignificant settlements and orders.
Quiet TitleCleared ownership, voided deeds, and addressed authorization disputes.

Products & Injury

Products Liability Defense

Defense for manufacturers, sellers, and businesses in catastrophic injury, wrongful death, and complex products litigation.

Need a deeper overview? Visit the Utah product liability attorney practice page for full service descriptions, summary judgment results, and consultation details.

Representative Cases

Leachman v. Rad Power BikesSummary judgment for e-scooter manufacturer; no defect evidence.
Biggs v. Hades Mgmt.Summary judgment for landowner; no duty to trespasser.
Elias v. Roth LandscapingSummary judgment in snow-removal premises case.
National Equipment v. KendrickSummary judgment for gas-station operator; settled after costs execution.
Gygi v. Marksman Mfg.Summary judgment for trailer manufacturer on design defect claims.
Leachman v. Magnum BikesSummary judgment for distributor after choice-of-law win under Colorado law.

Judgment

Judgment Enforcement

We convert judgments into recoveries: writs and receivers, asset location and seizure, sheriff's sales, and extended-liability litigation.

Services

Enforcement ToolsCharging orders, receivers, writs of attachment, garnishment, levy, and execution.
Asset Location & SeizureInvestigators, forensic accountants, and nationwide co-counsel.
Sheriff's SalesManaged end-to-end for real and personal property.
Extended LiabilityAlter-ego, successor, and fraudulent-transfer actions.

Trust & Probate

Trust & Probate Litigation

High-stakes trust and estate disputes for beneficiaries and fiduciaries, including trustee removal, accountings, undue influence, and emergency relief.

Need to freeze assets or neutralize misconduct immediately? The emergency TRO defense resource covers rapid injunction strategy for fiduciary and estate matters.

Representative Matters

Trustee MisconductRemoval, suspension, surcharge, and fee-shifting.
Capacity & Undue InfluenceAddressed late-stage beneficiary changes and no-contest clauses.
Authority & Real PartyCapacity to sue or defend, ratification, and substitution.
Unauthorized ModificationsAmendments and restatements exceeding authority.
Conflicts of InterestSelf-dealing, constructive trust, and disgorgement.
Emergency ReliefTROs and preliminary injunctions to freeze assets and prevent dissipation.

Speaking & Writing

Speaking & Writing

Moderator“The Strategic Role of Amicus Briefs in Appellate Practice,” Utah State Bar Virtual Summer Convention (July 9, 2024)
Speaker“Beyond the Bread: Bissonnette v. LePage Bakeries & Exemptions to the FAA,” Chicago, IL (May/Jun 2024)
SpeakerUtah State Bar Business Law Section, “Utah's Chancery Courts,” Salt Lake City (Apr. 22, 2024)
SpeakerDRI Annual Meeting, “Separation of Powers, Article III Standing, and Constitutional Injury in the Digital Era,” San Antonio (Oct. 26, 2023)
Ethics PresenterUtah State Bar Paralegal Division Annual Meeting, “Law Practitioners as Public Citizens and Doers of Justice” (Jun. 16, 2023)
Co-PanelistUtah State Bar Appellate Practice Section, “Preserving Your Appeal,” Utah Law & Justice Center (Mar. 2, 2023)
Presenter“Appellate Lawyers to the Rescue! The Preservation Rule and Beyond,” DRI Appellate Advocacy Seminar, San Diego (Nov. 4, 2022)
Article“How Appellate Courts Consider New Evidence on Appeal” (For the Defense, Feb. 2017)
Article“Accuracy and Clarity Promote Readability” (Utah State Bar, Nov. 10, 2016)
Presenter“Qualified Immunity Case Law Update” (UMAA, May 6, 2015)

Reviews

Reviews

Direct quotes from public platforms. Names omitted for privacy.

“Highly recommended. She moved the case forward and defended against misstatements.”

Best Lawyers

“Sarah is an amazing attorney. She did such a skillful job on my case.”

“If you need a smart, hard-working, and creative lawyer, I highly recommend Sarah Elizabeth Spencer.”

“Highly recommended... moved the case forward, educated the judge, and defended against blatant misstatements by the opposition.”

“Amazing representation in an insurance case. Prompt, available, fought hard.”

“Collections matter resolved with excellent results.”

“Excellent service, always prompt in communication.”

“Great to work with. Kept me informed.”

“Thorough—achieved a six-digit collection without trial.”

Sarah Elizabeth Spencer

About

About Sarah Elizabeth Spencer Willson

Started college at 13B.A. at 16J.D. at 21U.S. Supreme Court admitted

Commercial litigator and appellate advocate licensed in Utah and Colorado; admissions include the U.S. Supreme Court and multiple federal circuits. Two decades of trial and appellate experience across complex disputes—contract, fiduciary, fraud, property, and insurance coverage. Recognitions: Best Lawyers (2017–2026), Mountain States Super Lawyers, Utah Legal Elite, Utah Business Forty Under 40.

Of Counsel

Of Counsel

Matthew Bagley, Of Counsel at SpencerWillson

Matthew Bagley, Of Counsel

Licensed in Utah state and federal courts, Matthew brings decades of business and commercial litigation experience and a JD/MBA from BYU. He is fluent in Mandarin and Cantonese.

Read more

After law school, Matthew moved with his family to Hong Kong to serve as a legal consultant for Intel Semiconductor, handling anti-counterfeiting and trademark matters across the Asia-Pacific region. In 1996, he returned to Utah and joined a Salt Lake City firm as a commercial litigator. In 2008, he became Associate General Counsel at SecurityNational Financial Corporation.

He first worked with Sarah in 2009 when SecurityNational retained her firm on a case he managed in-house. Their successful collaboration across multiple matters led Sarah to recruit him to SpencerWillson in 2023. Today, he balances his role at the firm with his ongoing in-house position at SecurityNational.

Serves as Of Counsel to SpencerWillson. Primary employment at SecurityNational Financial Corporation; availability is matter-dependent.

Contact

Contact

215 + State Building, 215 S. State Street, Suite 700, Salt Lake City, Utah 84111

(+1) 801-346-8120
Sarah@SpencerWillsonPLLC.com
Salt Lake City, UT

For urgent matters involving emergency court proceedings, please contact the office by phone at 801-346-8120 or email Sarah@SpencerWillsonPLLC.com. I will respond within 3 hours to all messages regarding scheduled and pending court hearings for which you are seeking legal representation. Do not send confidential information. No attorney-client relationship is formed by contacting me; all engagements require a written and signed engagement letter.

Quick contact (no confidential info)

Do not send confidential information. No attorney-client relationship is formed by submitting this form.

Media

Press & Recognition

Media Highlights

Amicus Brief in U.S. Supreme Court Case Mead Johnson & Co. v. Greear

In August 2026, SpencerWillson authored an amicus curiae brief for the DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Illinois Defense Counsel urging the U.S. Supreme Court to review an Illinois Appellate Court decision that aggregated more than 12,500 nationwide claims in two Illinois counties, in tension with Daimler, Bristol-Myers Squibb, and Ford. The Court has since requested a response to the petition.

View brief
Amicus Brief in U.S. Supreme Court Case Hain Celestial v. Palmquist

In 2025, SpencerWillson authored an amicus curiae brief on behalf of the Atlantic Legal Foundation urging the U.S. Supreme Court to curb post-judgment vertical forum shopping and protect fairness in the appellate process.

View brief
Amicus Brief Supporting National Food-Labeling Standards

SpencerWillson also filed an amicus brief in Sprout Foods, Inc. v. Davidson (2025), advocating for the Supreme Court to maintain FDCA preemption and a uniform national food-labeling standard on behalf of the Atlantic Legal Foundation.

View brief

Latest News

Sep 11 2026 — Kirsten T. Taylor Passes the Utah Bar Exam

SpencerWillson, PLLC is thrilled to announce that Kirsten T. Taylor, the firm's longtime law clerk, has passed the Utah Bar Examination. Kirsten will be sworn in as a member of the Utah State Bar on October 13, 2026. Her research, drafting, and case-management work has been part of the firm's trial and appellate practice for years, and the firm looks forward to her continued contributions as a licensed attorney. Congratulations, Kirsten!

Sep 2026 — Sarah Elizabeth Spencer to Stand for Confirmation as Vice President of the Atlantic Legal Foundation

Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, who has served as Associate General Counsel of the Atlantic Legal Foundation (ALF) since July 2026, will stand for confirmation as ALF Vice President at the Foundation's Annual Fundraising Dinner this fall. Sarah and Kirsten T. Taylor will attend the dinner on behalf of SpencerWillson, PLLC. Founded in 1977, ALF is a nonpartisan public-interest law firm whose amicus curiae advocacy reaches the U.S. Supreme Court, the federal courts of appeals, and state appellate courts nationwide.

Sep 2026 — SpencerWillson, PLLC Relocates to the 215 + State Building

SpencerWillson, PLLC has moved its downtown Salt Lake City office to the 215 + State Building, 215 S. State Street, Suite 700, Salt Lake City, Utah 84111. The new office is a short walk from the Matheson Courthouse and the Utah Business & Chancery Court. Phone and email are unchanged: 801-346-8120 and sarah@spencerwillsonpllc.com.

Aug 7 2026 — SpencerWillson Files U.S. Supreme Court Amicus Brief in Mead Johnson & Co. v. Greear (No. 26-29)

Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, as counsel of record, authored a brief for the DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Illinois Defense Counsel as amici curiae supporting the petition for a writ of certiorari in Mead Johnson & Company, LLC v. Greear, on review from the Illinois Appellate Court, Fifth District. The brief argues that the decision below, which allowed more than 12,500 nationwide infant-formula claims to be aggregated in two Illinois counties, discards the general-jurisdiction rule of Daimler AG v. Bauman and the forum-claim connection required by Bristol-Myers Squibb and Ford Motor Co., creating a state-court substitute for federal multidistrict litigation without the safeguards of 28 U.S.C. § 1407. John M. Fitzgerald of Tabet DiVito & Rothstein LLC joined the brief. On September 1, 2026, the Court requested a response to the petition.

Jul 2 2026 — Sarah Elizabeth Spencer Joins Atlantic Legal Foundation as Associate General Counsel

SpencerWillson, PLLC is honored to announce that Sarah Elizabeth Spencer has been appointed Associate General Counsel of the Atlantic Legal Foundation (ALF), effective July 1, 2026. Founded in 1977, ALF is a nationally respected, nonpartisan public-interest law firm whose amicus curiae briefs are regularly relied upon in consequential cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, federal courts of appeals, and state appellate courts. Guided by a distinguished Board of Directors and Advisory Council under Chairman & President Hayward "Dan" Fisk, and working alongside Executive Vice President & General Counsel Lawrence S. Ebner, Sarah will help lead ALF's amicus program shaping arguments in precedent-setting appellate litigation nationwide. The appointment reflects Sarah's two decades of commercial litigation and appellate experience and her admission before the U.S. Supreme Court and multiple federal circuit courts.

Oct 20 2025 — Supreme Court Grants Review in Flowers Foods, Inc. v. Brock (No. 24-935)

The U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari in Flowers Foods, Inc. v. Brock (No. 24-935), addressing whether local delivery workers who handle goods that traveled in interstate commerce—but do not cross state lines—qualify as “transportation workers” under Section 1 of the Federal Arbitration Act. Sarah Elizabeth Spencer (counsel of record) and Lawrence S. Ebner co-authored an amicus brief for the DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and the Atlantic Legal Foundation; Ms. Spencer authored the sole amicus brief with Mr. Ebner. Merits briefing will proceed in the coming months.

Best Lawyers – Lawyer Logo
Aug 21 2025 — Sarah Elizabeth Spencer Named to The Best Lawyers in America® 2026

Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, Founder & Managing Attorney of SpencerWillson, PLLC, was recognized in the 2026 (32nd) edition of The Best Lawyers in America® for Commercial Litigation and Product Liability Litigation – Defendants. Selections are entirely peer-reviewed and not pay-to-play, reflecting broad confidence in Ms. Spencer’s skill and results.

Sep 2025 — SpencerWillson Challenges Utah Law to Protect Plaintiffs’ Rights

The firm filed Law Offices of Gabriel White v. State of Utah, seeking a declaratory judgment that the medical malpractice contingency-fee cap is unconstitutional and undermines access to justice.

Profile Feature — Sarah Spencer highlighted as “High-Achieving Adventurer” in Attorney at Law Magazine

The feature explored Sarah’s commercial litigation practice and her passion for extreme sports pursuits.

Jan 2025 — Sarah Spencer recognized by Best Lawyers in America for Commercial Litigation and Appellate Practice

Annual peer-reviewed recognition underscored Sarah’s performance across complex trials and appeals.

Nov 2024 — SpencerWillson briefs Utah State Bar Business Law Section on Business & Chancery Court

Sarah Spencer presented strategies for litigating in Utah’s statewide Business & Chancery Court docket.

Aug 2024 — Firm expands national appellate partnerships through DRI Center for Law & Public Policy and Atlantic Legal Foundation

SpencerWillson deepened collaboration on high-impact amicus initiatives supporting industry stakeholders.